Education Must Help In Meeting The Other

You are at the threshold of a ‘new you’. At a juncture like this, mixed emotions of excitement, anticipation, and maybe even a little bit of nervousness are perfectly normal. Be open to the new—a new you is possible.

There have been many National Education Commissions in India, starting from Radhakrishnan Commission in 1948. The Third, perhaps the most popular, education commission was the Kothari Commission in 1964. It was known for 10+2+3 structure, three language formula, scholarships, co-curricular activities, etc. The first sentence of its long report started with the sentence, the destiny of a nation is shaped in her classrooms. India/nation etc. seem very distant and far realities, they seem to be for the politicians and the bureaucrats. Let me slightly rephrase it, the destiny of a person is shaped in her/his classrooms. Classrooms are a place where ideas are generated, character is shaped, connections are formed, and once destiny is written.

We enter a classroom, a campus, or a new stage of education like you are doing today; there we meet new people, new friends, new teachers, new books, new ideas, and new perspectives. I would replace ‘new’ with ‘other’ for something new could be fancy and happy, and just something more convenient, but need not be challenging. Meeting the other is challenging. When we enter a new stage of education there must be possibility of meeting other people, other teachers, other books, other ideas, and other perspectives. That gives sense and relevance to a new stage of education.

Martin Heidegger, a modern philosopher, famously said, your destiny can’t be changed, but can be challenged. Every time we begin a new study, and for that matter begin anything, that challenges the way we had been so far, we are challenging our density.

Education in the age of AI is challenging. We live in an age of fake news, misinformation, repeated lies, propaganda, post truth, fundamentalism, and with the advent of the Internet and now AI we are flooded with information which are at times falsehood and distractions. With smartphones in our hands there is no dearth of information and knowledge. After the popularity of the printing press and spread of information in the 15^th century, it was English philosopher Francis Bacon (1561-1626) who had said, information / knowledge is power’. Now that we have plenty of it in our hands, we are becoming more and more confused, powerless, and vulnerable. Toady we are not able to decide whether the information and knowledge that we have is true or not, whether to believe it or not. Yuval Noah Harari corrects Francis Bacon in his book, 21 Lessons for the 21^st Century. He says, “In a world deluged by irrelevant information, clarity is power.”

Education today is an exercise in creating clarity. Every student must open up a debate, a research, with the mindset, I have heard this, but I must test this knowledge, I want to meet those people first hand, question that information myself, scrutinize them, etc. Deciphering truth from falsehood is a sacred act—and that is education.

Ratan Tata is the talk of the social media today. On 9 October 2024 India lost one of its finest citizens and industrialists, Ratan Tata; and in the same breath, he was perhaps India’s finest philanthropist too. As the news about his demise and condolences poured in on every social media and broadcast media, there was another face that was appearing on the margins and even being highlighted by many—Shantanu Naidu. They met in 2014, when Shantanu Naidu was just 21; their common interest was love for dogs.

Shantanu Naidu, as living and working with Ratan Tata has written a book of his experience with Ratan Tata, I Came Upon a Lighthouse: A Short Memoir of Life with Ratan Tata. In it he explains, how the entire universes conspires to make something happen; so many events, people, and in his case even dogs have to work together for two individuals to cross paths. And that happened in his meeting with Ratan Tata. Shantanu continues saying, when we see a lighthouse move towards it with all your force, and never away from it. Shantanu just moved towards Ratan Tata; and the rest is history.

As we begin this new academic year I wish and pray that you come upon many lighthouses, in the library, in books and ideas, in peers, in teachers, on corridor, in canteen; and may you have the courage to walk towards it. Welcome to the lighthouse experience called education.

From the speech given at the opening of the academic year for post graduate courses at IIPR 2024.

Comments

Why Do Some Nations and Establishments Fail?

The article, A Nobel for explaining why nations fail by Prashanth Perumal argues that the story of human progress is not written in stone but in the institutions we build. As the 2024 Nobel laureates have shown us, the difference between prosperity and poverty lies not in geography or destiny, but in the fundamental choices societies make about how to organise themselves. Like architects designing a home, our ancestors and current leaders craft the institutions that shelter our collective dreams. Some build inclusive structures, with strong foundations of democracy and private property rights, creating spaces where every citizen can contribute to and benefit from economic growth. Others construct extractive systems that may glitter temporarily but ultimately fail to provide sustainable shelter for their people's aspirations. The beauty of this understanding is its empowering message: nations aren't permanently destined to be rich or poor. The United States transformed from a

St. Francis Of Assisi—Take His Stories Seriously

From 2023-2026 we have a series of centenaries of St Francis of Assisi. Though lived only for just 44 years, the size and reach of his life is still growing. He has many names; we call him a brother, and at the same time, a mystic. A mystic is someone who does not operate from a place of faith, instead he has moved on to a place of knowledge, experience, and living; he/she does not need faith anymore. A mystic already lives what people of faith are only believing. This year is the 800 th anniversary of the Stigmata of St. Francis—he was a mystic and he was already there. Francis was born in 1181. He lived an unconscious, unattended, normal life, like any other, for first 24 years. Returning home from the Assisi-Perugia war, as a loser and wounded, Francis went through an awakening moment. One of the existential philosophers has a story of a stonecutter, whose only tool on which he trusted was a hammer. One day, as he was at his work, the hammer breaks, and the stonecutter fell on his

Fine Ways of Disregarding Vital Issues

Observing the preoccupations of Pharisees, scribes and religious leaders of his time (Mark 7: 1-23) Jesus commended that they have fine ways of disregarding the commandments of God in order to maintain human traditions and interests. They put aside weightier matters to uphold human decrees. In modern politics we hear the jargon, ‘politics of distraction’. In a country of mass illiteracy and unemployment, farmers’ suicide, etc. politicians and other key people divert public attention by discussing building temples, girls wearing hijab to college, etc. Noam Chomsky, an American social commentator says, “The key element of social control is the strategy of distraction that is to divert public attention from important issues and changes decided by political and economic elites, through the technique of flood or flooding continuous distractions and insignificant information.” The corrupt politicians must have learned this strategy from the pickpockets (or is it visa versa): they distra

UAPA And The Case Of Prof GN Saibaba

The article, Why does this gigantic state fear our hopes, our dreams? by YSR Murthy discusses the case of Professor G N Saibaba, a political dissident and prisoner of conscience in India. Here are the main points: Prof. Saibaba, disabled since childhood, became an activist and academic despite physical challenges. He was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2017 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) for alleged Maoist links. In October 2022, the Bombay High Court initially acquitted him, finding no valid sanction under UAPA. However, in March 2024, the High Court re-convicted him on merits. During his decade-long imprisonment, Saibaba faced harsh conditions and health deterioration. Despite this, his writings showed optimism and a refusal to give up on his ideals. The author argues that how the state deals with political dissidents and prisoners of conscience is a test of civilisational strength. As a country we are as weak and groundless as the laws that we have; and as

Choose To Understand Than Judge

In a world quick to condemn and eager to judge, there exists a profound truth that sets the empathetic apart: they seek not to judge but to understand. This principle, simple in its statement but revolutionary in its application, marks the difference between reactive thinking and true response. The impulse to judge is deeply human. We are pattern-seeking creatures, constantly categorising and evaluating our experiences and the people around us. This tendency served our ancestors well, allowing them to make split-second decisions crucial for survival. However, in our complex modern world, this same instinct often leads us astray, causing us to draw hasty conclusions and make decisions based on incomplete information. Wise individuals recognise this limitation. They understand that every human being is the product of countless influences: their upbringing, their struggles, their victories, their fears, and their dreams. Each person's actions, no matter how seemingly incomprehensible

Do Not Be A Wicked Generation

Knowing what is wrong and refusing to reject it and change is wickedness. Knowing what is right and truth and refusing embrace and support is wickedness. The people of Nineveh did not argue of resist when they heard they heard Jonah. There is someone greater than Jonah here. The queen of Sheba came from far to listen to the wisdom of Solomon, there is someone greater than Solomon here (Luke 11: 29-32). The people of Nineveh refused what is wrong; and the queen of Sheba embraced what is wise and truthful. India lost one of its finest industrialist who was a renowned philanthropist, Ratan Tata, on 9 October 2024. As this news and the events proceeding it flashed on the television and on social media, there was another face that was appearing and being highlighted by many—Shantanu Naidu. They met in 2014, when Shantanu Naidu was just 21; their common interest was love for dogs. Shantanu Naidu, as living and working with Ratan Tata has written a book of his experience with Ratan Tata,

SPRINGBOARDS and WALKING STICKS

Search This Blog