The Protection of Journalistic Freedom in India: Challenges and Progress

The article, SC steps in to protect journalists, underlines that the recent Supreme Court ruling in India against criminal cases for critical journalism marks a significant milestone in the ongoing struggle to protect press freedom and freedom of expression in the world's largest democracy. This essay examines the current state of journalistic freedom in India, the challenges faced by media professionals, and the implications of the Supreme Court's decision.

Freedom of the press is a fundamental pillar of democracy, enshrined in Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution. However, as the article highlights, journalists in India have faced numerous obstacles in recent years, including intimidation, harassment, and legal challenges. The use of criminal cases against journalists for their critical reporting has been a particularly concerning trend, potentially stifling free speech and investigative journalism.

The Supreme Court's ruling reaffirms that journalists should not be prosecuted merely for their writings or criticism of the government. This decision is crucial in several aspects:

Constitutional Reinforcement: It strengthens the constitutional right to free speech, emphasizing that criticism of the government is a vital aspect of democracy.
Legal Protection: The ruling provides a legal shield for journalists against arbitrary criminal cases, potentially reducing self-censorship.
Democratic Principles: It underscores the importance of a free press in maintaining a healthy democracy and holding power to account.

Despite this positive development, the article points out several ongoing challenges:

Safety Concerns: Journalists continue to face threats of violence and intimidation.
Legal Hurdles: The use of draconian laws, such as the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, against journalists remains a concern.
Media Ownership: Changes in ownership and consolidation in the media industry potentially compromise editorial independence.
International Rankings: India's low ranking in the World Press Freedom Index (161st out of 180 countries in 2023) reflects the persistent challenges faced by the media.

The article also highlights the broader context of press freedom in India. It mentions the resignation of senior news anchors, changes in media ownership, and the constant pressure faced by journalists. These factors contribute to a complex media landscape where freedom of expression is continually negotiated and contested.

The Supreme Court's ruling is a step in the right direction, but its effectiveness will depend on its implementation and the broader societal and political context. As noted by the journalist Stanley Carvalho, the author of the article, this decision serves as a reminder of the vital role that a strong and independent media plays in ensuring good governance and social progress in a democracy.

SC steps into protect journalists, by Stanley Carvalho. In: The Deccan Herald, 10 October 2024.

In conclusion, while the Supreme Court's ruling represents a significant victory for press freedom in India, it is clear that ongoing vigilance and further reforms are necessary to ensure a truly free and independent media. The challenges faced by Indian journalists underscore the need for continued legal protections, societal support, and international attention to uphold the principles of free speech and press freedom in the world's largest democracy.

Comments

Third-Day Is The Most Optimistic Day in The Scriptures

Hosea the prophet had to go through much because he was a prophet; he was even asked to get married to a prostitute in the town. Yet, Hosea says, “Come, let us return to the Lord. He has torn us to pieces but he will heal us; he has injured us but he will bind up our wounds…. On the third day he will restore us” (Hosea 6:1-2). Retreat is this day (days) of restoration; retreat is we, revisiting our God. The third day is the most optimistic day. The Gospels repeatedly speak of the third day. After losing the boy Jesus, on the third day, his parents found him in the temple (Luke 2:41-52). Jesus returns to his parents on the third day; perhaps he said sorry too. The third day is a day of returning home, returning to the community; it is a day to forgive and ask forgiveness. One of the biggest confidence of Jesus was that he had not lost anyone who was given to him, to his care (John 18:9). On the third day, there was a marriage in Cana in Galilee, and when they ran short of wine Jesus

Go And Preach The Gospel

For St. Francis, the gospel was everything, and the only thing to follow. Young Francis was inspired and caught up with the gospel. He was drawn to it; but at the same time confused. Once after hearing the gospel in a church, he went to the sacristy and asked the old priest, ‘Is the gospel an ideal form of living or is it a mandate for living?’ The priest caught between the gap between his life and the gospel. But later with honesty and courage the priest said, the gospel is a mandate for living. If it is an ideal form of living, a lot of compromise will take place. If it is a mandate for living there is no escape. Matthew 10: 6-16 gives us a mandate as to how to go around the world preaching. These are the guidelines for discipleship. Here the lifestyle of the disciples is defined. He sent them two by two. In Jewish tradition, if something has to be established as true, another has to second what you are saying; so it was sensible to send them two by two. Further, we need brothers a

Dig Deep Enough, And Blessings Come To You

Life is flat like a field on which the farmer was digging in Matthew 13: 44-46. But the idea is that if you dig deep enough you will find treasures in your life, however flat your life may be, as the farmer found treasure in his flat field. In life, revival is possible. The first question of Jesus, ‘who do people say that I am’ was just a process of information gathering. The second question, ‘who do you say that I am’ demanded an answer from the disciples (Matthew 16:13-20). An unquestioned life goes nowhere. The disciples went into a moment of silence. They had to dig deep. However flat the life of peter was, when he dug deep enough, he could see, hear the revelation of the Father, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.” Having heard the answer of Peter, Jesus gives Peter, the other disciples, and all of us, four blessings: on you (Peter) the rock I will build my church, never will the power of death over come the church, I will give you the keys of the heaven; whatever yo

St. Francis Of Assisi—Take His Stories Seriously

From 2023-2026 we have a series of centenaries of St Francis of Assisi. Though lived only for just 44 years, the size and reach of his life is still growing. He has many names; we call him a brother, and at the same time, a mystic. A mystic is someone who does not operate from a place of faith, instead he has moved on to a place of knowledge, experience, and living; he/she does not need faith anymore. A mystic already lives what people of faith are only believing. This year is the 800 th anniversary of the Stigmata of St. Francis—he was a mystic and he was already there. Francis was born in 1181. He lived an unconscious, unattended, normal life, like any other, for first 24 years. Returning home from the Assisi-Perugia war, as a loser and wounded, Francis went through an awakening moment. One of the existential philosophers has a story of a stonecutter, whose only tool on which he trusted was a hammer. One day, as he was at his work, the hammer breaks, and the stonecutter fell on his

Uncompromising Starting Points Of Discipleship

Living according to the Gospel also makes us pay a price (Luke 9: 57-62). Jesus was magnetic; many got attracted to him spontaneously. Nobody gives his or her life for a cause that is dead. They all wanted to follow Jesus, but could not sustain because of three reasons. Foxes have holes, and the birds of the air have nests, but the son of man has no place to lay his head. You are condemned to be in perennial disturbance. You will be homeless. You almost are not supposed to be happy, meaning enjoying the pleasures of life. Being joyful is a gospel value. There is a difference between happiness and joy ( santhosham vs anandam ). Jesus had a home; being there Jesus remained homeless. Pastoral care is our anxiety over the people. ‘Jesus found them like sheep without a shepherd.’ He had compassion for them.’ I will bury my father and come back. It is often read as ‘let me fulfill my domestic responsibilities,’ but the passage does not indicate that his father or mother is dead. Jesus

Being Spiritual Is a Never-Ending Process

It is a constant occurrence in the gospels that Jesus comes in conflict with the religious authorities of his time, on food and fasting, on washing hands and pots, on Sabbath and prayer, and even on the idea of god. In Luke 6: 1-5 too the same happens on food and working on a Sabbath. It has been a troubling urge and itch of humanity, and also of the church, to decide clear-cut boundaries for God, boundaries for doing good; thus make their existence acceptable and comfortable. All systems exclude, expel, punish, and protect to find identity for their members in ideological perfection or some kind of “purity.” Richard Rohr in Everything Belongs argues, i t seems that we Christians have been worshiping Jesus’ journey instead of doing his journey. If your prayer is not enticing you outside your comfort zones, if your Christ is not an occasional “threat,” you probably need to do some growing up and learning to love. And he goes on to say; “God is always bigger than the boxes we build

Who Is The Greatest?

The disciples of Jesus disputed among themselves, perhaps not for the first or for the only time, about “who is the greatest among them” (Luke 9: 46-50). Most people do this at least in their mind. Many of us are fake great people. We just feel that we are great, and act as one. Feeling great without being great is a dangerous thing. Jesus gives them two parameters to measure one’s greatness. How do you treat insignificant people? Jesus takes a little child and places her in the midst of them, and tells them, ‘Whoever welcomes this little child in my name is the greatest.” Greatness depends on one’s capacity to accept people who are poor, handicapped, slow in understanding, etc. with our constant exposure to religious activities we are able to empathize, spend time with those who are less privileged than us. How do we deal with people who are equal to us? John brings up a serious matter to Jesus, their master, namely, he saw someone driving out demons in Jesus’ name and they tried to

SPRINGBOARDS and WALKING STICKS

Search This Blog